| | Artist | Points
  | Songs |
|---|
| 1. | Arthur Collins & Byron Harlan | 650 | 01/1909 • Alabam' • 81 pts
01/1909 • Honey Lou • 67 pts
02/1909 • The Right Church, but the Wrong Pew • 119 pts
03/1909 • Down Among the Sugar Cane • 102 pts
04/1909 • The Sweetest Gal in Town • 81 pts
04/1909 • Yip-I-Addy-I-Ay! • 61 pts
10/1909 • My Wife's Gone to the Country (Hurrah! Hurrah!) • 81 pts
12/1909 • Down at the Huskin' Bee • 61 pts |
| 2. | Ada Jones | 548 | 03/1909 • I Remember You • 102 pts
07/1909 • Beautiful Eyes • 102 pts
10/1909 • My Pony Boy • 102 pts
10/1909 • Mister Othello • 51 pts
11/1909 • I've Got Rings on My Fingers • 118 pts
11/1909 • Red Head • 73 pts |
| 3. | Ada Jones & Billy Murray | 522 | 03/1909 • Pet Names • 55 pts
04/1909 • Oh, You Kid! • 55 pts
05/1909 • Shine On, Harvest Moon • 118 pts
06/1909 • I'm Looking for a Sweetheart and I Think You'll Do • 73 pts
07/1909 • Isn't Love a Grand Old Thing? • 67 pts
10/1909 • I'm Awfully Glad I Met You • 86 pts
12/1909 • I'm Glad I'm a Boy - I'm Glad I'm a Girl • 67 pts |
| 4. | Henry Burr | 493 | 01/1909 • Then You'll Remember Me • 81 pts
04/1909 • When You and I Were Young, Maggie • 73 pts
05/1909 • To the End of the World with You • 118 pts
09/1909 • I Wonder Who's Kissing Her Now • 119 pts
11/1909 • Honey on Our Honeymoon • 102 pts |
| 5. | Billy Murray | 469 | 02/1909 • Good Evening, Caroline • 81 pts
03/1909 • When a Fellow's on the Level with a Girl Who's on the Square • 67 pts
05/1909 • I Wish I Had a Girl • 102 pts
05/1909 • American Ragtime • 61 pts
08/1909 • My Cousin Caruso • 73 pts
12/1909 • Dixie Land, I Love You • 86 pts |
| 6. | Billy Murray & the Haydn Quartet | 387 | 03/1909 • Sullivan • 73 pts
05/1909 • Meet Me in Rose-Time, Rosie • 67 pts
08/1909 • Take Me Up with You, Dearie • 81 pts
10/1909 • Take Me Out for a Joy Ride • 81 pts
12/1909 • The Hat My Father Wore on St. Patrick's Day • 86 pts |
| 7. | The Haydn Quartet | 378 | 02/1909 • Brown Eyes, Good-Bye • 86 pts
10/1909 • Up, Up, Up in My Aeroplane • 86 pts
12/1909 • Lonesome • 86 pts
12/1909 • Put On Your Old Gray Bonnet • 120 pts |
| 8. | Blanche Ring | 254 | 07/1909 • Yip-I-Addy-I-Aye • 81 pts
10/1909 • I've Got Rings on My Fingers • 118 pts
10/1909 • The Billiken Man • 55 pts |
| 9. | Frank Stanley & Henry Burr | 250 | 04/1909 • In the Garden of My Heart • 102 pts
05/1909 • Softly and Tenderly • 47 pts
06/1909 • Shine On, Harvest Moon • 102 pts |
| 10. | Sousa's Band | 223 | 02/1909 • Under the Double Eagle • 86 pts
02/1909 • Fairest of the Fair (March) • 51 pts
04/1909 • El Capitan March (new version) • 86 pts |
| 11. | Harry Lauder | 223 | 02/1909 • When I Get Back Again to Bonnie Scotland • 61 pts
09/1909 • She is My Daisy • 102 pts
09/1909 • He was Very Kind to Me • 61 pts |
| 12. | Manuel Romain | 214 | 03/1909 • I Wish I Had a Girl • 61 pts
05/1909 • To the End of the World with You • 81 pts
10/1909 • I Wish I Had My Old Gal Back Again • 73 pts |
| 13. | Byron G. Harlan | 213 | 06/1909 • Schoolmates • 73 pts
11/1909 • Lonesome • 67 pts
12/1909 • Let's Go in to a Picture Show • 73 pts |
| 14. | The Peerless Quartet | 208 | 04/1909 • Roses Bring Dreams of You • 67 pts
08/1909 • My Pony Boy • 86 pts
11/1909 • Sweetheart's a Pretty Name When It's Y-O-U • 55 pts |
| 15. | Bob Roberts | 201 | 06/1909 • Shine On, Harvest Moon • 67 pts
08/1909 • I Love My Wife, but Oh You Kid! • 73 pts
10/1909 • My Wife's Gone to the Country, Hurrah! Hurrah! • 61 pts |
| 16. | Harry Tally | 201 | 04/1909 • I Wish I Had a Girl • 81 pts
05/1909 • In Those Good Old Country Days • 73 pts
11/1909 • When I Dream in the Gloaming of You • 47 pts |
| 17. | Frank Stanley & Elise Stevenson | 192 | 01/1909 • Good Evening, Caroline • 118 pts
12/1909 • It's Hard to Kiss Your Sweetheart (When the Last Kiss Means Good-Bye) • 73 pts |
| 18. | Arthur Collins | 188 | 08/1909 • I Love, I Love, I Love My Wife, but Oh You Kid! • 102 pts
09/1909 • That's a-Plenty • 86 pts |
| 19. | Will Oakland | 182 | 06/1909 • Silver Threads Among the Gold • 81 pts
07/1909 • Nobody Knows, Nobody Cares • 102 pts |
| 20. | Harry Macdonough & Elise Stevenson | 171 | 04/1909 • Shine On, Harvest Moon • 119 pts
04/1909 • The Message of the Red Rose • 51 pts |
| 21. | Arthur Pryor's Band | 132 | 01/1909 • National Emblem March • 51 pts
07/1909 • 1812 Overture • 81 pts |
| 22. | Nat Wills | 128 | 01/1909 • No News, or What Killed the Dog • 81 pts
10/1909 • The Traveling Man • 47 pts |
| 23. | Cal Stewart | 121 | 04/1909 • Uncle Josh on a Fifth Avenue Bus (new version) • 61 pts
08/1909 • Uncle Josh at a Baseball Game • 61 pts |
| 24. | Edward M. Favor | 107 | 09/1909 • I Love My Wife, but Oh You Kid! • 51 pts
12/1909 • Sadie Salome, Go Home! • 55 pts |
| 25. | Walter Van Brunt | 86 | 11/1909 • When I Dream in the Gloaming of You • 86 pts |
| 26. | Frank Stanley & Byron G. Harlan | 86 | 03/1909 • Meet Me in Rose-Time, Rosie • 86 pts |
| 27. | Harold Jarvis | 86 | 02/1909 • Beautiful Isle of Somewhere • 86 pts |
| 28. | Ralph Herz | 86 | 02/1909 • That Wasn't All! • 86 pts |
| 29. | Prince's Orchestra | 73 | 03/1909 • Washington Post March • 73 pts |
| 30. | Frank Stanley | 67 | 10/1909 • Cupid's Telephone • 67 pts |
| 31. | Vess Ossman | 61 | 03/1909 • A Gay Gossoon • 61 pts |
| 32. | The Victor Light Opera Co. | 61 | 11/1909 • Gems from The Prince of To-Night • 61 pts |
| 33. | Harry Macdonough | 55 | 02/1909 • There Never Was a Girl Like You • 55 pts |
| 34. | Cal Stewart & Len Spencer | 55 | 07/1909 • Uncle Josh's Trip to Coney Island • 55 pts |
| 35. | Evan Williams | 51 | 03/1909 • The Song That Reached My Heart • 51 pts |
| 36. | Elizabeth Wheeler | 51 | 11/1909 • The Last Rose of Summer • 51 pts |
| 37. | Harvey Hindermyer | 47 | 07/1909 • Nobody Knows, Nobody Cares • 47 pts |
